How the bracket number is calculated

Game nights show each Commander deck as its bracket and a number, "Bracket 3: Upgraded (3.6)". Here's what the number means.

The number in two halves

The whole part is the deck's Commander bracket: the higher of what the rules checks find and what the owner declares.

The decimal is how much of the cEDH toolkit the deck has, from none of it (.0) to maxed out on all of it (.9).

The score is absolute, not relative to the bracket: a slow deck with no fast mana, tutors or combos reads about x.0 in whatever bracket it's declared.

It's truncated, so the top of Bracket 3 shows 3.9, never 4.0.

For example, a deck the checks put in Bracket 3 with 64% of the toolkit reads "Bracket 3: Upgraded (3.6)".

The four parts

The decimal is a score from 0 to 1 made of four parts. Each part is 0 to 1 from what it counts, capped at 1, and the parts are weighted into the score.

Speed: 30% of the score (how fast it gets going)

Fast mana
50% of the part
Mana rocks and dorks at mana value 1 or less, and rituals. 8 count in full.
Average mana value
30% of the part
Of the spells: 3.6 or more counts as none, 1.8 or less in full.
Untapped lands
20% of the part
In full with no lands that always enter tapped, none once 40% of the lands do.

Consistency: 30% of the score (how often it finds what it needs)

Tutors
50% of the part
Not land tutors. 10 count in full.
Game Changers
30% of the part
Cards on the Commander Game Changers list. 8 count in full.
Draw
20% of the part
Card draw: the first 6 count as none, 16 in full.

Compactness: 25% of the score (how few cards it needs to win)

Combos
up to 100% of the part
Commander Spellbook's combos in the deck. A two-card combo counts 1; each piece past two halves it. A combo whose cards cost 6 mana or less in all counts up to 1.5x, one twice that 0.5x. Ruthless combos count 1.5x and Spicy ones 1.25x; one with a commander 1.5x. Combos of three or more pieces count up to 2x with 10 tutors. The best combo counts in full and each next one 50% of the one before; 3 in all count in full.
Extra turns
4% each of the part
Extra turn cards.
Mass land denial
8% each of the part
Cards Commander Spellbook flags as mass land denial.

Interaction: 15% of the score (how cheaply it stops others)

Removal and counterspells
100% of the part
By what they cost: a free one counts 1, mana value 1 or less 0.8, 2 0.5, 3 or more 0.2. 12 in all count in full.

Things to know

  • It's absolute, not relative to the bracket: the same cards score the same in any bracket.
  • It's truncated: the top of Bracket 3 shows 3.9, never 4.0.
  • It never moves a deck across brackets: only the rules checks and the owner's declared bracket do.
  • A deck that hasn't been scored yet shows no decimal at a game night, and counts as the middle of its bracket.
  • It reads the cards' roles (tutor, draw, removal...) from Scryfall's tags and the combos from Commander Spellbook, so a missing tag or combo moves it.

This will change

The weights and caps above get retuned as we see how decks score, so a deck's number can move without the deck changing. This is version 1 of the scoring.